Steaks are the mainstay of cast iron pans, and probably the reason most people own one. If you like cooking steaks at home, and by extension are not one of those poor, strange outcasts that likes steaks well done, then you'll probably want to know how to cook one to taste like they do in restaurants. And there are a couple of simple tricks (butter, we meet again), but honestly nothing will make a bigger difference than using a proper cast iron pan. Thankfully, cast iron pans are also the home of great bacon, cornbread, and delicious eggs.
Do it. |
The other great thing is because they're basically a single forged piece of metal, cast iron pans are relatively cheap and they last for decades. I remember my grandmother making the most mindblowing potato wedges in lard in this cast-iron pan, and 20 years later it is still in fantastic condition. Cast iron pans that come with a non-stick coating are more expensive, but save yourself the money and put the effort in to season it yourself - trust me, it's worth it.
Unseasoned on the left, old and dirty on the right |
Scrubbed clean, and ready to be seasoned |
Seasoning for the first time
When you first buy a cast-iron pan, it won't have any seasoning on it (make sure to avoid "non-stick" cast-iron pans because that misses the point entirely). Or, if you get a second hand one or a hand-me-down like I did, it will probably be a bit rusty and the seasoning will be pretty knackered. So what you have to do is scrape/rub all the rust and dirt off of it, and wash it thoroughly with soapy warm water. Keep in mind that this is the ONLY time soapy water will ever touch the pan, because once you season it you must never clean it with any detergent or soap, as it will both ruin the taste and destroy the seasoning. Once you've got a nice clean, smooth cast iron pan, you're ready to start seasoning it.
This is what it should start to look like as you use it |
After an hour or so, come back and turn on your strongest burner to full heat (ideally gas). Get the best, most reliable oven glove you have, and very carefully remove the pan from the oven and put it onto the gas burner. For the love of your uncharred flesh, understand that at this point the pan will be hotter than hades, so be extra careful. Leave the pan on the burner for 10 minutes or so, and then turn off the heat. Leave the pan to cool (this will take a lot longer than you think). When it's warm to the touch, put a couple of teaspoons of oil into the pan and rub the insides with a paper kitchen towel. Do this every now and then after you've used it. You've now got a seasoned cast-iron pan! This is the start of a beautiful relationship.
Your new best friend |
The wonderful thing about this pan is that once you start to use it, it works for so many great things. It's your go-to for steak, it makes bacon taste better, it handles eggs no problem (watch the heat), hell you can even make pizza with it.
For now, let me leave you with a quick guide to making an awesome steak:
- Turn your oven to it's maximum setting (220+ C), chuck the pan into the oven face up.
- Leave it in there for a good 15-20 minutes while you prep the steak.
- Rub the steak with salt, pepper, and oil (avoid olive oil due to its low smoke point. Groundnut ideally, vegetable/corn oil will do).
- Very carefully take the pan out of the oven and put on your hottest burner at max heat, leave it for a few minutes.
- NEVER pour oil directly into the cast iron pan, unless you fancy having some fun with your fire extinguisher.
- When the pan is screaming hot and smoking, toss the steak in and DO NOT touch it for at least a minute.
- Once you turn over the steak the first time, chuck in a small knob of butter and baste the steak with the juices.
- At this point, instructions differ wildly depending on the cut, the thickness and how you like your steak. For a thinner, leaner cut for example, you can just sear it in the pan and you're done. For a thicker, fattier cut like a solid ribeye, you would sear it in the pan to get a nice crust, then chuck it in the oven for a minute or two on each side to finish it off nicely. It really depends on what cut of meat you've got and how you like it.
- Once you're done cooking, scrape out any bits that have stuck to the pan, wash it out with hot water (remember, no soap!) and dry thoroughly. Pop a few drops of oil into the pan, rub the inside and store it away.
I wish I could tell you there was a shortcut to cooking steak perfectly every single time, but there isn't. I've been practising for years and I still get it wrong if I'm using an unfamiliar cut or size. Using the touch test (quick tip: your cheek is rare, your chin is medium, your forehead is well done) and getting a sense of timing through practice, you'll get it right more often than not. And with a proper cast iron pan on your side, it will taste sublime.